Connect with us

PHOTOSPEAKS

Can You Trademark A Colour??? Christian Louboutin In Serious Court Battle To Retain His Red Soled High Heels Trademark

Published

on

image

Can you trademark a color? That’s basically what’s at issue in the lawsuit filed by shoemaker Christian Louboutin – known for his red soled shoes — that sought to stop YSL from selling shoes that are all red, including red soles.

The shoemaker’s red soled heels aren’t holding up well in the ongoing legal battle against YSL’s solid red shoes.

The birth of the red soled Loubou goes like this: In 1992 Louboutin saw an assistant painting her nails a bright red and decided to varnish the soles of his stilettos the same shade. He has explained: “This happened by accident as I felt that the shoes lacked energy so I applied red nail polish to the sole of a shoe. This was such a success that it became a permanent fixture.”

Before you could say “shoes to die for,” the bright red sole became the instant ID of a pair of super expensive Loubous and the recognizable status symbols were worn by Sarah Jessica Parker, Blake Lively, Mary Kate and Ashley Olsen and Scarlett Johansson on and off the Hollywood red carpets

In 2008, he also obtained a US Patent and Trademark for his signature red sole shoes, which are priced from $535 to $4,645 a pair on the Barneys website. So in the spring of 2011, Louboutin decided to sue Yves St. Laurent for trademark infringement for making red soled 2011 cruise footwear. The YSL shoes in question are not simply red soled, the entire shoe is bright red..


Eventually, New York Judge Victor Marrero decided not to give Louboutin permission to stop YSL from making their shoes. He argued that “Awarding one participant in the designer shoe market a monopoly on the color red would impermissibly hinder competition among other participants,” He compared it to Picasso suing Monet for painting his water lilies with a distinctive indigo that Picasso used when painting water. Marrero also called into question the validity of the designer’s trademark.

A group of eminent law professors has sided with YSL. Academics from some of the US’s most famous law schools filed a brief with the Federal Court of Appeals in Manhattan in early January urging the court not to allow Louboutin to “monopolize” the hue. and suggested that the appeal “be rejected in order to preserve freedom of innovation and competition.”

At his Jan. 24  appeal of the decision, Louboutin sat in the New York Court of Appeals with his well-heeled fashion friend Diane von Furstenberg while three judges reviewed the initial decision. Presiding Judge José Cabranes asked if the designer wanted to trademark “the color red,” as suggested by YSL.
“We don’t claim basic red,” explained Louboutin lawyer Harley Lewin, who insisted the designer only wanted to protect “a particular color, in a particular place, on a particular item.”

The three-judge panel reserved decision in the case, where Louboutin claims YSL
 infringed on his trademark by producing women’s shoes using the “Chinese Red” soles long associated with his work.

Louboutin’s post court statement was: “The company remains confident that the appeals court will adhere to its conviction that the red sole, this integral and long-held part of the brand’s identity and recognized by consumers worldwide, will continue to be recognized as the Christian Louboutin trademark.”
Tell us: Should a company be permitted to trademark a particular color on a particular article in a particular place? And what would that to do the Fashion World?

Chivido 2024: “Oya Come My Wedding” - Davido Taunts People Claiming He’s Too Accessible
Entertainment12 hours ago

Chivido 2024: “Oya Come My Wedding” – Davido Taunts People Claiming He’s Too Accessible

Chelsea Agrees £19m Deal With Aston Villa For Teenager Star, Omari Kellyman
Sports13 hours ago

Chelsea Agrees £19m Deal With Aston Villa For Teenager Star, Omari Kellyman

Davido Abandoned Imade Because I Refused To Sleep With Him - Sophia Momodu
Celebrities14 hours ago

Davido Abandoned Imade Because I Refused To Sleep With Him – Sophia Momodu

Unregistered Tiger Nut Drinks Caused Lagos Cholera Outbreak, Death Toll Rises To 24
Health15 hours ago

Unregistered Tiger Nut Drinks Caused Lagos Cholera Outbreak, Death Toll Rises To 24

Sister Of Abuja Cab Driver Accused By Daniella Peters Denies Kidnap Allegations [Video]
Celebrities17 hours ago

Sister Of Abuja Cab Driver Accused By Daniella Peters Denies Kidnap Allegations [Video]

Ayra Starr Reveals Why She Can No Longer Stand Straight
Entertainment19 hours ago

Ayra Starr Reveals Why She Can No Longer Stand Straight

Fubara Appoints Wodo To Replace Wike’s Ally Awuse As Chairman Of Rivers Traditional Rulers Council
Politics19 hours ago

Fubara Appoints Wodo To Replace Wike’s Ally Awuse As Chairman Of Rivers Traditional Rulers Council

Dammy Krane Continues 'Murder' Allegations Against Davido Despite Cease And Desist Letter
Entertainment22 hours ago

Dammy Krane Continues ‘Murder’ Allegations Against Davido Despite Cease And Desist Letter

How I Was Almost Kidnapped By A Cab Driver In Abuja - BBNaija’s Daniella Peters
Celebrities23 hours ago

How I Was Almost Kidnapped By A Cab Driver In Abuja – BBNaija’s Daniella Peters

Davido Issues Cease And Desist To Dammy Krane, Threatens Defamation Lawsuit
Entertainment24 hours ago

Davido Issues Cease And Desist To Dammy Krane, Threatens Defamation Lawsuit

Journalist Joe Waksi Found Dead Days After He Was Declared Missing In Abuja
Metro2 days ago

Journalist Joe Waksi Found Dead Days After He Was Declared Missing In Abuja

A Man Can Have 5 Girlfriends, But If Your Wife Dates Another Man, Your Life Is In Danger - Joe Igbokwe
Celebrities2 days ago

A Man Can Have 5 Girlfriends, But If Your Wife Dates Another Man, Your Life Is In Danger – Joe Igbokwe

"They Tried To Stop Davido, Chioma’s Wedding But God’s Will Happened" - Cubana Chief Priest [Video]
Entertainment2 days ago

“They Tried To Stop Davido, Chioma’s Wedding But God’s Will Happened” – Cubana Chief Priest [Video]

The Engagement Ring I Gave Chioma Can Buy 3 Rolls Royce - Davido Brags [Video]
Entertainment2 days ago

The Engagement Ring I Gave Chioma Can Buy 3 Rolls Royce – Davido Brags [Video]

"I’ll Never Be A 50/50 Man" – IK Osakioduwa Says He'll Never Split Bill With His Wife [Video]
Celebrities2 days ago

“I’ll Never Be A 50/50 Man” – IK Osakioduwa Says He’ll Never Split Bill With His Wife [Video]

Kano Government Orders Bayero's Eviction From Mini Palace, Demolition Of Building
News2 days ago

Kano Government Orders Bayero’s Eviction From Mini Palace, Demolition Of Building

Jaywon Tackles Ayra Starr And Her Supporters For Disrespectful Use Of Their Photo
Entertainment2 days ago

Jaywon Tackles Ayra Starr And Her Supporters For Disrespectful Use Of Their Photo

Bianca Censori Goes Topless In Suspenders For Dinner With Kanye West [Photos]
Celebrities2 days ago

Bianca Censori Goes Topless In Suspenders For Dinner With Kanye West [Photos]

Kanayo Accuses Angel Unigwe And Her Mother Of Contract Breach, Threatens Disruptions [Video]
Entertainment2 days ago

Kanayo Accuses Angel Unigwe And Her Mother Of Contract Breach, Threatens Disruptions [Video]

“I Have Only 10 Years Left To Look Beautiful” – Kim Kardashian
Celebrities2 days ago

“I Have Only 10 Years Left To Look Beautiful” – Kim Kardashian